Field Notes · Topic
IS Theory
Core theoretical foundations of the Information Systems discipline — theory building, variance vs. process, causal structure, and the evolution of IS constructs.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Alignment Has a Stakeholder ProblemAlignment is usually described as alignment with human values. The papers that built the method say it aligned models to a small group of people, and IS research on trust shows that creator, user and system pull in different directions.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Alignment Is a Process, and IS Has Studied That Process BeforeIS alignment research spent thirty years moving from alignment as a state to alignment as continual adjustment. AI alignment research is now making the same move, and the older field has lessons to offer.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Needs Two Parties Who Know Different ThingsA model and a person who know the same things make a weak team. In the evidence, the gains come from what one side knows and the other does not, and that is an information system design question.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Needs a Stopwatch, Not Only a SurveyIn three studies of AI help at work, what people believed about their speed and what was measured did not match, and the gap ran in both directions.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Is a Question of Who Hands Work to WhomAlmost every experiment puts the person last, deciding after the AI speaks. Workers, experts and one study that let the model hand out the work suggest that the direction of delegation is a design choice.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Is Judged Against the Wrong BarMost human-AI teams beat the person working alone. Far fewer beat the better of the two. The bar we choose decides what we end up calling success.
- AI & Agentic SystemsSuperintelligence Is a Construct Without an Agreed MeasureEvery major definition of superintelligence uses a different yardstick, and expert forecasts move by decades when the question is reworded. For an IS reader that looks like a construct problem before it looks like a risk problem.
- AI & Agentic SystemsControl Over Superintelligence Is Handed Over Before It Is TakenThe careful sources do not describe a machine that seizes power. They describe organizations that delegate decisions one at a time under competitive pressure, and delegation is an IS construct.
- Comps & ReflectionsBought a $2M Platform, Nobody Learned a ThingOrganizations buy expensive analytics platforms and learn nothing. The theory of absorptive capacity explains why prior knowledge, not capital, determines whether new technology becomes intelligence or noise.
- IS TheoryPeople Use Tools Inside Activity Systems, Not in a VacuumActivity theory says you cannot understand tool use without the full activity system around it. The same tool in two systems means two completely different things.
- IS TheoryActor-Network Theory: Why Your ERP System Is an Actor TooANT treats software, databases, and infrastructure as actants with the same analytical standing as humans. In IS research, that changes everything about how we study implementation.
- IS TheoryThe Gap Between What a System Can Do and What People Do With ItAffordance actualization explains why two organizations using the same system get completely different results. The technology affords possibilities. People and context determine what happens.
- IS TheoryThe Door Handle Is Not for EveryoneAn affordance is not a feature. It is an action possibility for a specific actor with a specific goal in a specific context. Most IS papers get this wrong.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Agents Create a Principal-Agent Problem at Machine SpeedThe AI alignment problem is principal-agent theory with a new degree of freedom: the agent can act faster than human oversight can keep up.
- AI & Agentic SystemsCopilot Generated More Code and More BugsThirty percent acceptance is adoption, not effective use. Burton-Jones and Grange defined effective use as faithful domain representation, not output.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhen AI Acts Like a Colleague: Structuration in the Agent EraMultiagent AI systems are not just tools being used. They act, and their outputs become part of the organizational structure that shapes the next cycle.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI's Energy Problem Is a Sociotechnical Systems ProblemTraining AI models consumes staggering amounts of energy. Trist and Bamforth showed in 1951 why optimizing only the technical subsystem creates a collapse.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy Doctors Resist Better AI: Identity Matters as Much as AccuracyAI outperforms radiologists at detection but hospitals do not adopt it. Identity theory explains why. The tools that succeed will verify professional identity, not threaten it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Implementation Failures Are Often SociotechnicalBostrom and Heinen said in 1977 that MIS failures are sociotechnical. Half a century later, AI implementation fails the same way.
- AI & Agentic SystemsTiny Teams, Big Questions: What Happens When AI Writes the CodeGartner says two-person AI-augmented teams will deliver what twenty-person teams do today. Baird and Maruping predicted this years ago. The real question is not team size but delegation governance.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Output Is a Boundary Object. That Is Why It Is So Hard to Govern.Star and Griesemer defined boundary objects in 1989. AI output fits the definition perfectly. And that is why every governance policy that treats it as a single type of thing fails.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI as a Participant in the Work System, Not Only a ToolAlter's work system framework already has a slot for AI. It is not the technology element. It is the participant element.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Safety Frameworks Are PMT Without Using the NameAI safety warnings raise threat appraisal sky high. Without coping appraisal, they produce fear control, not safety.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Security Platforms Are Governance Boundary ResourcesWhen 80% of unauthorized AI use is internal policy violations, AI security platforms are governance products, not security products.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Supercomputing Alone Is Not a MoatEvery major cloud vendor now sells GPU clusters. The hardware is commodity. The capability to use it is not. Here is what Carr and Barney teach us about AI moats.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy the Spreadsheet Everyone Complains About SurvivesStar and Griesemer's boundary objects are plastic enough to serve local needs but robust enough to hold shared identity. That is why the spreadsheet survives.
- IS TheoryTechnology and Organizations Shape Each Other. That Is Not a Metaphor.Coevolution means the relationship between technology and organizations is recursive and ongoing. What you build changes how you work, which changes what you need to build.
- IS TheoryWhy Your IS System Behaves in Ways No One Fully DesignedComplex adaptive systems exhibit emergence, coevolution, and chaos. Modern IS is one of them. Designing for predictability alone is the wrong goal.
- Comps & ReflectionsThree Hours on One Page of Orlikowski and Iacono (2001)I had read Orlikowski and Iacono before. Three hours on one page taught me what I had missed about the five views of the IT artifact.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy I Keep Rereading the Same 20 PapersEach reread of the same foundational IS papers reveals something new: the claim, then the evidence, then the limits, then the connections across decades.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Theory I Thought Was Pointless Until My Third ReadI rolled my eyes when a study partner said critical realism was important. Three reads later I apologized, at least internally.
- AI & Agentic SystemsI Read DiMaggio and Powell While Watching Every Company Announce an AI StrategyStudying institutional theory for comps changed how I read the news. Every AI-first press release is mimetic isomorphism. I cannot unsee it.
- Comps & ReflectionsMarkus and Robey 1988 Keep Showing UpThe further I get into comps, the more I see Markus and Robey's three causal stances in every paper. It is not just one paper anymore. It is the lens.
- Comps & ReflectionsMy Comps Study Notes Are a DisasterMy comps notes are a wreck of sticky notes, marginalia, and inconsistent filenames. The mess is not a sign of failure. It is how real understanding happens.
- Comps & ReflectionsMy Study Partner Said I Was Wrong About Structuration TheoryI confused structuration theory's three modalities with institutional theory's three pillars for months. A study partner caught it, and getting corrected was the best thing that happened to my comps prep.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Theory Map That Keeps GrowingOne page of sticky notes became a wall of connected IS theories. RBV, dynamic capabilities, structuration, affordances, institutional theory: the connections between them matter as much as the theories themselves.
- Comps & Reflections56% of IS Papers Do Not Theorize TechnologyReading Sarker et al. (2019) for the third time during comps prep, the 56% stat finally hit me: more than half of IS papers do not theorize technology at all.
- IS Research MethodsThe World Exists Whether You Measure It or NotCritical realism says reality has layers we cannot fully observe, and most IS research ignores the deepest one.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy No One Reads Your DashboardDashboards fail when they are built for reporting instead of decision-making. DeLone and McLean show why, and Torres and Sidorova show what to do about it.
- IS Research MethodsDesign Science Is Not Just Building ThingsBuilding a working artifact is necessary but not sufficient for design science research. The real question is whether your artifact produces generalizable knowledge grounded in theory.
- IS Research MethodsDesign Science Research in IS: Building Things That Produce KnowledgeHevner et al. (2004) argued that IS should not only explain and predict but also build and evaluate artifacts. Twenty years later, the paper still shapes how we think about what counts as IS research.
- IS TheoryDigitizing a Bad Process Makes It a Faster Bad ProcessMost companies claiming digital transformation are doing digitization. Vial, Wessel et al., and Bharadwaj et al. give you the tools to tell the difference.
- IS TheoryA Digital Artifact Is Not Just CodeDigital artifacts are both material and semiotic at once. You cannot study the system without studying its social life, and you cannot study the social without the system.
- AI & Agentic SystemsEdge AI Moves Computation Into the Physical World. STS Says That Changes Everything.When AI runs on a factory sensor or hospital monitor instead of the cloud, the technical subsystem becomes physically distributed and harder to monitor. STS theory warned us seventy years ago what happens next.
- Comps & ReflectionsLogging In Is Not UsingNinety percent login rates tell you almost nothing about whether a system is doing its job. Burton-Jones and Grange showed why measuring adoption instead of effective use is the wrong question.
- IS TheoryWhy Enterprise Software Is Universally HatedThe person who signs the check never has to use the tool. That structural gap explains more about enterprise adoption than any UX framework ever will.
- IS Research MethodsWhat Ethnography Actually Demands of an IS ResearcherEthnography means embedding yourself in a setting long enough to see what is really happening, not the version people perform for a survey.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy IS Research Keeps Extending TAM Instead of Replacing ItTAM was built for email and word processors. Now it explains AI agents, blockchain, and VR. The IS field knows how to replace theories, so why does it keep choosing extension instead?
- AI & Agentic SystemsYour AI Strategy Found the Problem It Wanted to SolveCohen, March and Olsen showed that in real organizations, solutions arrive before problems. The AI strategy wave is the clearest recent example.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYou Are Not Your Job TitleMost technology resistance is not about the technology. When a tool threatens who someone believes they are, rejection is identity-consistent, not irrational.
- IS TheoryInformation Processing Theory: Organizations Are Processors, Not MachinesGalbraith (1974) said organizations design themselves to handle the information their tasks demand. IS exists to close the gap between what a task requires and what people can process alone.
- IS TheoryThe Hospital and the Startup Are Not Playing the Same GameDifferent institutional logics give people different definitions of rational. Market logic says grow fast; clinical logic says do no harm. When they clash in healthcare, banking, or education, technology alone cannot bridge the gap.
- IS TheoryInterdisciplinary IS Research: Opportunity or Identity Crisis?IS borrows from almost every social science discipline. That flexibility is the field's strength and the source of its deepest ongoing argument.
- IS Research MethodsIS Research Borrows Constantly. That's the Problem and the Point.IS draws its theories from economics, sociology, psychology, and computer science. The result is a discipline with a persistent identity problem and an unusual opportunity.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDeLone and McLean's IS Success Model Works for AI If You Flip Who the User IsDeLone and McLean's IS success model applies to AI systems when you expand 'user' to include both humans and the downstream systems that consume AI output.
- IS Research MethodsThe IS Success Model and What It Misses TodayDeLone and McLean built the most cited IS success model for transactional systems. Most software today is something else entirely.
- IS Research MethodsIT Capability and Organizational Performance: What the Research ShowsThe productivity paradox asked why IT spending didn't show up in productivity data. The answer turned out to be about capability, not spending.
- IS TheoryTechnology Neither Determines Nor SubmitsMarkus and Robey gave IS three ways to think about causation. Two of them are traps. The third is where almost every real phenomenon lives.
- IS TheoryMove Fast and Break Things Is the Longwall Method for SoftwareTrist and Bamforth showed in 1951 that optimizing only the technical subsystem destroys the social one. Silicon Valley rediscovered this lesson and called it a strategy.
- AI & Agentic SystemsMultiagent Systems Are Mainly a Coordination ProblemGartner says multiagent systems inquiries surged 1,445% but the real gap is not better agents. It is coordination architecture.
- IS TheoryParadox Theory and the Tensions That Don't ResolveSmith and Lewis (2011) built a theory around organizational tensions that are simultaneously contradictory and interdependent. The goal is not to resolve them. It's to manage them.
- IS TheoryPhysical AI Is Affordance Theory Made ConcreteWarehouse robots, autonomous vehicles, and drones make affordance theory literal in a way that software never could. Misreading what a robot affords is not a UX problem.
- IS TheoryThe Platform Decides Who WinsPlatforms are not pipelines. When you confuse the two, you miss who actually holds the power and why the rules are never neutral.
- IS TheoryThe Real Test Is Month SevenBhattacherjee's ECM shows continuance is driven by confirmed expectations, not by initial adoption drivers. The expectation gap is what kills systems at month seven.
- IS TheoryThe Privacy Paradox Is Rational If You Stop Calling It IrrationalPeople share data on fitness apps but panic about Facebook. The so-called privacy paradox disappears once you realize the calculus includes factors researchers kept ignoring.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhen a New Label on an Old Idea Falls Short of a ContributionMost IS papers are improvements dressed as inventions. Sun et al. say you need novelty, rigor, and relevance, not two out of three.
- IS TheoryResource-Based View and IT as Competitive AdvantageMost IT purchases fail the VRIN test. The interesting question is what IT-related resources actually are hard to imitate.
- IS TheoryResource Dependency Theory and the IT Sourcing ProblemPfeffer and Salancik said dependence on external resources shapes power relationships. In IT sourcing, that means vendor lock-in is not a contract problem. It is a structural one.
- AI & Agentic SystemsRLHF Is Structuration Theory: We Train AI, Then AI Trains UsRLHF mirrors Giddens' duality of structure, creating a recursive loop where human preferences shape AI outputs and reshape human preferences.
- AI & Agentic SystemsOrganizations Don't Choose Tech, They Rationalize ItWeick's sensemaking theory says people act first and make sense later, preferring plausibility over accuracy. That explains everything from the Twitter rebrand to EU AI regulation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsShadow AI Is Shadow IT All Over Again, Just FasterFollowing Ferneley and Sobreperez, three workaround types explain why employees bypass official AI tools. Shadow AI is task-technology fit failure, not compliance failure.
- IS TheorySignaling Theory and What Technology Choices CommunicateSpence (1973) showed that costly observable signals communicate unobservable qualities. Technology choices do this constantly. What you run says something beyond what it does.
- IS TheoryJoint Optimization Is Not a Feel-Good SloganThe origin story of sociotechnical systems theory is not a feel-good tale about teamwork. It is a cautionary tale about what happens when you optimize only the machines.
- AI & Agentic SystemsStop Counting Users, Start Measuring DelegationWhy 'use' is the wrong construct for agentic AI, and what delegation theory actually means for how we study human-AI interaction.
- IS TheoryGiddens in IS: Why the Same System Produces Different OrganizationsGiddens built structuration theory around structure and agency being mutually constitutive. Orlikowski pointed it at technology, and IS has never been the same since.
- IS TheorySame Tool, Different Department, Total DisasterWhy the same ERP or Slack deployment thrives in one department and collapses in another, explained through structuration theory, Orlikowski's duality of technology, and adaptive structuration.
- IS TheorySome People Are Just Not Ready (And That Is Data, Not a Flaw)Most adoption models treat resistance as the absence of adoption. But resistance is its own construct with its own causes, and ignoring it means your model is doing half the job.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe IT Artifact Is Not Optional56% of IS papers study the social side without theorizing technology at all. The field's identity crisis is not rhetorical. The numbers show it is real.
- IS TheoryThe Productivity Paradox Is Still AliveWe keep spending more on technology and expecting more productivity. The same trap keeps catching us. Here is why the IS research community saw this coming decades ago.
- IS Research MethodsTheory Testing vs. Theory Building: When Each Is AppropriateIS research tests existing theory more than it builds new theory. There is value in testing. But after hundreds of TAM extensions, we should be honest about how small the marginal contribution of each new study has become.
- IS TheoryWhat TikTok Understands About User Behavior That Your Enterprise App Does NotVenkatesh added hedonic motivation, habit, and price value to UTAUT for consumer contexts. Enterprise software still runs on the utilitarian-only version. That gap is why TikTok and Slack win while expense reporting tools get memed.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Specification Error in Your Trust VariableTrust, trustworthiness, reliance, and delegation operate at different levels with different antecedents. Treating them as interchangeable is not a measurement choice, it is a theoretical mistake.
- IS Research MethodsYour Regression Can't Explain a DivorceMohr warned us in 1982 that variance and process theories answer different questions and need different evidence. Most IS research still evaluates process stories with variance criteria. Here is why that is a mistake.
- AI & Agentic SystemsVibe Coding Is Sociotechnical Systems Theory Testing Its LimitsAI-native platforms let anyone generate code from a prompt. Trist and Bamforth showed in 1951 why optimizing only the technical subsystem creates a maintenance crisis.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhat Makes a Good IS Paper?Technically correct IS papers fail all the time. The difference between a paper that passes review and one that advances the field is harder to name than it sounds.
- IS TheoryWhat Theory Actually Is (And What It Isn't)References, data, variables, diagrams, and hypotheses are not theory. But then what is? A tour through the papers that shaped how IS researchers answer that question.
- IS Research MethodsWhen Bit Strings Get Social PowerA digital object is more than code on a server. Faulkner and Runde show that bit strings occupy social positions with rights and responsibilities, and that changes everything about how we study IT.
- AI & Agentic SystemsExplainable AI as Sensemaking: Why Plausibility Matters Alongside AccuracyWeick said people prefer plausible stories over accurate ones. XAI built tools for accuracy. It has been solving the wrong problem since 1995.
- IS Research MethodsYour Paradigm Is Not NeutralPositivist, interpretive, and critical realist research each carry assumptions about what is real and how we can know it. None of them is just a method choice.
- IS TheoryZero-Trust Architecture Is Already Founded on Trust ResearchZero-trust architecture is not about eliminating trust. It is about institutionalizing the calibrated trust that IS researchers have studied for decades.
No notes found. Try another word or topic.