Field Notes ยท Topic
Organizational Theory
Institutional theory, dynamic capabilities, organizational learning, ambidexterity, and how organizations change and adapt.
- AI & Agentic SystemsIn AI Alignment, the Feedback Channel Is an Information SystemAlignment by human feedback depends on raters, pay schemes, sampling rules and review steps. Agency theory saw this coming, because it treats information as a commodity that has a cost and can be gamed.
- Comps & ReflectionsBought a $2M Platform, Nobody Learned a ThingOrganizations buy expensive analytics platforms and learn nothing. The theory of absorptive capacity explains why prior knowledge, not capital, determines whether new technology becomes intelligence or noise.
- IS TheoryThe Door Handle Is Not for EveryoneAn affordance is not a feature. It is an action possibility for a specific actor with a specific goal in a specific context. Most IS papers get this wrong.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhen the Algorithm Fails, Who Takes the Call?Agency theory explains IT outsourcing and governance through principals, agents, and monitoring. AI rewrites the problem in a way the original framework did not anticipate.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Spreads Through Social Networks as Much as Tech BudgetsRogers, Granovetter, and Burt explain why the department with the AI champion adopts faster while the department across the building with the same budget does not.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy AI Adoption Produces ROI for Some and a Headache for OthersTOE from Tornatzky and Fleischer explains why most AI investments fail while a few transform organizations: the three contexts must align.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Creates an Ambidexterity Challenge Every Organization Is FailingOrganizations use AI to optimize existing processes while calling it transformation. March (1991) would call this pure exploitation, and the exploration gap is getting dangerous.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhen AI Acts Like a Colleague: Structuration in the Agent EraMultiagent AI systems are not just tools being used. They act, and their outputs become part of the organizational structure that shapes the next cycle.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Ethics Boards and the Pull of Legitimacy Over PerformanceMeyer and Rowan predicted that organizations adopt structures for legitimacy, not performance. AI ethics boards are the most direct example I have seen.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adopted the Way the Garbage Can Model PredictsCohen, March and Olsen showed that solutions search for problems, not the other way around. Most organizations adopted AI exactly that way between 2023 and 2025.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy Doctors Resist Better AI: Identity Matters as Much as AccuracyAI outperforms radiologists at detection but hospitals do not adopt it. Identity theory explains why. The tools that succeed will verify professional identity, not threaten it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI and the Labor Market: What IS Research Can ContributeEconomists study macro displacement. IS researchers can study what actually happens inside organizations when AI changes specific jobs, roles, and power structures.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Output Is a Boundary Object. That Is Why It Is So Hard to Govern.Star and Griesemer defined boundary objects in 1989. AI output fits the definition perfectly. And that is why every governance policy that treats it as a single type of thing fails.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy AI Pilots Don't Become ProductsAlmost every large organization has run an AI pilot. Very few of those pilots make it to production. That gap is not a data science problem.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYour AI Policy Is Just Your Old IT Policy With AI Pasted InAlmost every AI policy is a find-and-replaced IT acceptable-use policy. DiMaggio and Powell explain why that pattern is not lazy. It is institutional isomorphism.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Supercomputing Alone Is Not a MoatEvery major cloud vendor now sells GPU clusters. The hardware is commodity. The capability to use it is not. Here is what Carr and Barney teach us about AI moats.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Training Data Made the Knowledge-Based View VisibleThe New York Times lawsuit against OpenAI is the Knowledge-Based View of the firm becoming visible in court and in every training data licensing negotiation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Lowers the Cost of Coordination, So Why Are Organizations Still Siloed?Transaction cost economics predicts that when AI cuts coordination costs, organizations should restructure. But they are not. What gives?
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Vendor Concentration Creates a New Resource DependencyPfeffer and Salancik said dependence rises when resources are critical and concentrated. AI model providers are the most concentrated critical resource in IS history.
- Comps & ReflectionsStrategy Is What Your Organization Actually Pays Attention ToOcasio's attention-based view says firm behavior follows what executives notice, not what they intend. Attention is the scarcest organizational resource.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy the Spreadsheet Everyone Complains About SurvivesStar and Griesemer's boundary objects are plastic enough to serve local needs but robust enough to hold shared identity. That is why the spreadsheet survives.
- Organizational TheoryMaking Do: How Bricolage Explains Improvised IS InnovationBricolage explains why organizations without the right tools often build something better than the official system. Making do with what's at hand is not failure.
- Organizational TheoryBYOD and the IT Department's Impossible ChoiceWhen the iPhone became better than the company laptop, IT departments had to decide how much control was worth the fight. Neither option was clean.
- Organizational TheoryChange Management in IS Implementation: The Part That Gets UnderbudgetedIS implementations routinely underinvest in change management. The technology budget gets line items. The people budget gets a rounding error.
- IT Governance & StrategyThe CIO Role Has Changed But Job Descriptions Have NotCIOs are expected to drive strategy and innovation. Many still report to the CFO. That gap is not accidental.
- IS TheoryTechnology and Organizations Shape Each Other. That Is Not a Metaphor.Coevolution means the relationship between technology and organizations is recursive and ongoing. What you build changes how you work, which changes what you need to build.
- AI & Agentic SystemsI Read DiMaggio and Powell While Watching Every Company Announce an AI StrategyStudying institutional theory for comps changed how I read the news. Every AI-first press release is mimetic isomorphism. I cannot unsee it.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Practice Exam Question I Got Wrong That Changed EverythingI answered a practice comps question about coercive isomorphism completely wrong. That mistake reshaped how I study for exams.
- Comps & ReflectionsMy Study Partner Said I Was Wrong About Structuration TheoryI confused structuration theory's three modalities with institutional theory's three pillars for months. A study partner caught it, and getting corrected was the best thing that happened to my comps prep.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Theory Map That Keeps GrowingOne page of sticky notes became a wall of connected IS theories. RBV, dynamic capabilities, structuration, affordances, institutional theory: the connections between them matter as much as the theories themselves.
- IT Governance & StrategyDigital Transformation Needs the CEO, Not Just the CIOThe leadership gap in digital transformation is not a technology problem. It is a culture and authority problem that technology cannot fix.
- IS TheoryDigitizing a Bad Process Makes It a Faster Bad ProcessMost companies claiming digital transformation are doing digitization. Vial, Wessel et al., and Bharadwaj et al. give you the tools to tell the difference.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDomain-Specific AI Needs Domain-Specific Knowledge to WorkGartner says 60 percent of enterprise GenAI models will be domain-specific by 2028. But a domain-specific model cannot compensate for an organization that lacks domain-specific prior knowledge.
- IT Governance & StrategyDynamic Capabilities and Why Agility Is Not a BuzzwordTeece, Pisano, and Shuen's dynamic capabilities framework explains why having excellent systems today guarantees nothing about tomorrow.
- Organizational TheoryWhy CIOs Get Fired After ERP ImplementationWhen ERP implementations fail, the postmortem always says the software was fine and the change management was missing. That phrase hides what actually happened: the organization lacked the political will to standardize processes.
- IT Governance & StrategyWhy ERP Implementations Keep FailingAfter decades of high-profile disasters, large organizations still repeat the same ERP mistakes. The problem is rarely the software.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe EU AI Act Is Institutional Theory Playing Out in Real TimeThe EU AI Act hits all three of Scott's institutional pillars at once. Here is why that makes it the most consequential IS policy since GDPR.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYour AI Strategy Found the Problem It Wanted to SolveCohen, March and Olsen showed that in real organizations, solutions arrive before problems. The AI strategy wave is the clearest recent example.
- Comps & ReflectionsGeopatriation Is Institutional Logics Colliding with Cloud StrategyGeopatriation is not a cloud architecture decision. It is an institutional choice about which logic dominates.
- AI & Agentic SystemsGPU Dependency Is Resource Dependency Theory in a $200B MarketPfeffer and Salancik predicted this. When one supplier controls access to a critical resource, power concentrates. NVIDIA at 80% GPU market share changes everything.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYou Are Not Your Job TitleMost technology resistance is not about the technology. When a tool threatens who someone believes they are, rejection is identity-consistent, not irrational.
- Organizational TheoryInformation Overload: Simon Was RightHerbert Simon said we can't process everything. That was 1947. We've spent 80 years building systems that prove him right every single day.
- Comps & ReflectionsInstitutional Entrepreneurship: Who Gets to Change the Rules?Institutional theory explains why organizations conform. Institutional entrepreneurship explains who breaks that conformity and rewrites the rules everyone else must follow.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy So Many AI Strategies Look AlikeMost organizations adopting AI are not making rational decisions. They are responding to coercive, mimetic, and normative pressure that makes copying feel like strategy.
- IS TheoryThe Hospital and the Startup Are Not Playing the Same GameDifferent institutional logics give people different definitions of rational. Market logic says grow fast; clinical logic says do no harm. When they clash in healthcare, banking, or education, technology alone cannot bridge the gap.
- IT Governance & StrategyShadow IT Is Intrapreneurship With a Compliance ProblemWhen employees spin up unauthorized cloud accounts and build their own tools, they are being intrapreneurial. The question is whether organizations can harness that without losing control.
- AI & Agentic SystemsIS Research Has an Environmental Cost Problem It Mostly IgnoresDigital infrastructure consumes significant electricity. IS researchers studying digital transformation should be asking who measures, reports, and governs the IT carbon footprint.
- Comps & ReflectionsIT Outsourcing: Why We Keep Doing the Same ThingOrganizations outsource IT, run into problems, bring it back in-house, then outsource again. The cycle is predictable. The reasons it repeats are not mysterious.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy Knowledge Management Systems Usually FailNonaka's SECI model explains why most knowledge management systems only solve half the problem, and the easy half at that.
- IT Governance & StrategyLegitimacy Theory and Why Organizations Adopt Technology They Don't NeedOrganizations sometimes adopt technology not because it works but because not adopting it would look bad. Legitimacy theory explains why this is rational.
- AI & Agentic SystemsModel Collapse Is Path Dependence Hitting AI Training DataThe same path dependence and absorptive capacity dynamics that explain organizational learning traps also explain why models degrade when trained on their own output.
- IT Governance & StrategyNo-Code and Low-Code: The Limits of the Citizen DeveloperNo-code platforms lower the floor for simple tasks. They don't raise the ceiling. When the use case gets complex, the citizen developer needs an engineer.
- IT Governance & StrategyBig Companies Don't Fail at Innovation. They're Too Good at Not-Innovation.March (1991) called it the competency trap: organizations get so good at what they currently do that they stop investing in what they will need to do next.
- IT Governance & StrategyRunning the Business and Changing It at the Same TimeMarch's exploration-exploitation tradeoff applies to IT strategy more directly than almost any other management domain. Bimodal IT was an attempt to solve it. Here is why that attempt keeps failing.
- Organizational TheoryWhy the Same System Fails in One Hospital and Works in AnotherCulture operates below the level where IS implementations are designed. Schein's three levels explain why EHRs and ERPs keep running into invisible walls.
- IS TheoryParadox Theory and the Tensions That Don't ResolveSmith and Lewis (2011) built a theory around organizational tensions that are simultaneously contradictory and interdependent. The goal is not to resolve them. It's to manage them.
- IT Governance & StrategyQuantum Computing and What It Actually Means for Information SystemsQuantum hardware is real, but enterprise-ready it is not. Here is what the IS field should be watching anyway.
- IS TheoryResource-Based View and IT as Competitive AdvantageMost IT purchases fail the VRIN test. The interesting question is what IT-related resources actually are hard to imitate.
- IS TheoryResource Dependency Theory and the IT Sourcing ProblemPfeffer and Salancik said dependence on external resources shapes power relationships. In IT sourcing, that means vendor lock-in is not a contract problem. It is a structural one.
- Organizational TheoryRoutine Dynamics and Why Processes Keep Reverting to the Old WayFeldman and Pentland (2003) showed that routines contain the seeds of both stability and change. IS implementations often change the documented process while leaving the actual one intact.
- AI & Agentic SystemsOrganizations Don't Choose Tech, They Rationalize ItWeick's sensemaking theory says people act first and make sense later, preferring plausibility over accuracy. That explains everything from the Twitter rebrand to EU AI regulation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsShadow AI Is the New Shadow ITEmployees are pasting internal documents into consumer AI tools. The risk profile is different from shadow IT, but the pattern is identical.
- AI & Agentic SystemsShadow AI Is Shadow IT All Over Again, Just FasterFollowing Ferneley and Sobreperez, three workaround types explain why employees bypass official AI tools. Shadow AI is task-technology fit failure, not compliance failure.
- IS TheorySignaling Theory and What Technology Choices CommunicateSpence (1973) showed that costly observable signals communicate unobservable qualities. Technology choices do this constantly. What you run says something beyond what it does.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Network You Have Is Part of the SystemSocial capital theory says the network around a system determines whether the system works. IS treats this network as a constant. It is not.
- IS TheoryJoint Optimization Is Not a Feel-Good SloganThe origin story of sociotechnical systems theory is not a feel-good tale about teamwork. It is a cautionary tale about what happens when you optimize only the machines.
- Organizational TheorySpatial Computing and the Quieter Enterprise AR StoryWhile the consumer metaverse flopped, enterprise AR kept growing quietly. Apple Vision Pro brought spatial computing back to the headlines, but the real story started years earlier on factory floors.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe System That Teaches NothingEnterprise knowledge systems capture what can be written down and miss everything else. Argyris, Nonaka, and Cohen tell us why.
- IS TheoryThe Productivity Paradox Is Still AliveWe keep spending more on technology and expecting more productivity. The same trap keeps catching us. Here is why the IS research community saw this coming decades ago.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy the Same CRM Thrives in One City and Dies in AnotherThe TOE framework explains why identical technology adoption fails in one organization and succeeds in another: context is not background, it is the whole story.
- IT Governance & StrategyTwo-Speed IT: Running Today and Building TomorrowGartner's bimodal IT concept is appealing in theory. The execution is where things get complicated, and expensive, and politically strange.
- Comps & ReflectionsOne Million Vulnerabilities and Counting: Why Patching Alone Cannot ScaleGartner projects one million vulnerabilities annually by 2030. Patching cannot scale. The only move is to reconfigure how the firm approaches software risk.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhen Employees Break the System, That's a Requirements DocumentFerneley and Sobreperez argued workarounds are not user failure but evidence of system-task misfit. The workaround is the real requirements document.
No notes found. Try another word or topic.