Field Notes ยท Topic
AI & Agentic Systems
Artificial intelligence, generative AI, agentic systems, and the governance, trust, and adoption challenges they create for organizations.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Alignment Has a Stakeholder ProblemAlignment is usually described as alignment with human values. The papers that built the method say it aligned models to a small group of people, and IS research on trust shows that creator, user and system pull in different directions.
- AI & Agentic SystemsIn AI Alignment, the Feedback Channel Is an Information SystemAlignment by human feedback depends on raters, pay schemes, sampling rules and review steps. Agency theory saw this coming, because it treats information as a commodity that has a cost and can be gamed.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Alignment Is a Promise the Organization MakesWhen an organization's AI contradicts what the organization says it values, trust and reliance fall. Alignment is also a promise about control and accountability across a supply chain, which brings security into the picture.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Alignment Is a Process, and IS Has Studied That Process BeforeIS alignment research spent thirty years moving from alignment as a state to alignment as continual adjustment. AI alignment research is now making the same move, and the older field has lessons to offer.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Needs Two Parties Who Know Different ThingsA model and a person who know the same things make a weak team. In the evidence, the gains come from what one side knows and the other does not, and that is an information system design question.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Needs a Stopwatch, Not Only a SurveyIn three studies of AI help at work, what people believed about their speed and what was measured did not match, and the gap ran in both directions.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Is a Question of Who Hands Work to WhomAlmost every experiment puts the person last, deciding after the AI speaks. Workers, experts and one study that let the model hand out the work suggest that the direction of delegation is a design choice.
- AI & Agentic SystemsHuman-AI Collaboration Is Judged Against the Wrong BarMost human-AI teams beat the person working alone. Far fewer beat the better of the two. The bar we choose decides what we end up calling success.
- AI & Agentic SystemsSuperintelligence Is a Construct Without an Agreed MeasureEvery major definition of superintelligence uses a different yardstick, and expert forecasts move by decades when the question is reworded. For an IS reader that looks like a construct problem before it looks like a risk problem.
- AI & Agentic SystemsControl Over Superintelligence Is Handed Over Before It Is TakenThe careful sources do not describe a machine that seizes power. They describe organizations that delegate decisions one at a time under competitive pressure, and delegation is an IS construct.
- AI & Agentic SystemsIn the Superintelligence Race, More Information Can Mean More DangerA simple model of an AI race finds that teams are safest when they know nothing about each other's capabilities. Openness turns out to have several dimensions, and IS knows something about designing disclosure.
- AI & Agentic SystemsSuperintelligence Risk Is Managed by Organizations, Not Only by ModelsThe most practical part of the catastrophic risk literature is about safety culture, separation of duties and stolen model weights. That is organizational and security ground, and IS already studies it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhen the Algorithm Fails, Who Takes the Call?Agency theory explains IT outsourcing and governance through principals, agents, and monitoring. AI rewrites the problem in a way the original framework did not anticipate.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Internet of Agents Will Be Built by Platforms That Own the ProtocolThe platform that controls the agent communication protocol will control the Internet of Agents, just as Google owned search and Apple owned mobile.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Follows the S-Curve. Most Organizations Are Still in the Chasm.Rogers showed that innovation adoption follows an S-curve. Enterprise AI is not stalling. It is exactly where diffusion theory predicts.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Spreads Through Social Networks as Much as Tech BudgetsRogers, Granovetter, and Burt explain why the department with the AI champion adopts faster while the department across the building with the same budget does not.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy AI Adoption Produces ROI for Some and a Headache for OthersTOE from Tornatzky and Fleischer explains why most AI investments fail while a few transform organizations: the three contexts must align.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Agents Create a Principal-Agent Problem at Machine SpeedThe AI alignment problem is principal-agent theory with a new degree of freedom: the agent can act faster than human oversight can keep up.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Creates an Ambidexterity Challenge Every Organization Is FailingOrganizations use AI to optimize existing processes while calling it transformation. March (1991) would call this pure exploitation, and the exploration gap is getting dangerous.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Chatbots Feel Like the Richest Medium but Behave Like a Search EngineAI chatbots feel like a face to face conversation but function like a search engine with a confidence problem. Media richness theory explains why that mismatch is dangerous.
- AI & Agentic SystemsCopilot Generated More Code and More BugsThirty percent acceptance is adoption, not effective use. Burton-Jones and Grange defined effective use as faithful domain representation, not output.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhen AI Acts Like a Colleague: Structuration in the Agent EraMultiagent AI systems are not just tools being used. They act, and their outputs become part of the organizational structure that shapes the next cycle.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI's Energy Problem Is a Sociotechnical Systems ProblemTraining AI models consumes staggering amounts of energy. Trist and Bamforth showed in 1951 why optimizing only the technical subsystem creates a collapse.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Ethics Boards and the Pull of Legitimacy Over PerformanceMeyer and Rowan predicted that organizations adopt structures for legitimacy, not performance. AI ethics boards are the most direct example I have seen.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adopted the Way the Garbage Can Model PredictsCohen, March and Olsen showed that solutions search for problems, not the other way around. Most organizations adopted AI exactly that way between 2023 and 2025.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy Better Models Alone Won't Solve the Hallucination Trust ProblemHallucination is framed as a retrieval bug to be engineered away. Lee and See would call it a trust calibration failure, and that framing changes the solution entirely.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy Doctors Resist Better AI: Identity Matters as Much as AccuracyAI outperforms radiologists at detection but hospitals do not adopt it. Identity theory explains why. The tools that succeed will verify professional identity, not threaten it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Gap Between Fair Metrics and Fair Experience (Amazon's AI Hiring Edition)Kattnig et al. (2024) showed a model can satisfy every fairness metric and still feel deeply unfair. Amazon's AI hiring tool proved it with real damage.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Implementation Failures Are Often SociotechnicalBostrom and Heinen said in 1977 that MIS failures are sociotechnical. Half a century later, AI implementation fails the same way.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI and the Labor Market: What IS Research Can ContributeEconomists study macro displacement. IS researchers can study what actually happens inside organizations when AI changes specific jobs, roles, and power structures.
- AI & Agentic SystemsCritical Realism Explains Why AI Models Are Not the Mechanisms They SimulateAI models predict patterns in observed data but never access the generative mechanisms that produce them. Critical realism tells us why that ceiling is not a technical problem.
- AI & Agentic SystemsTiny Teams, Big Questions: What Happens When AI Writes the CodeGartner says two-person AI-augmented teams will deliver what twenty-person teams do today. Baird and Maruping predicted this years ago. The real question is not team size but delegation governance.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Has The Strongest Network Effects Ever, And That Is a ProblemNetwork effects theory explains why AI markets concentrate around a few providers and why the data flywheel makes it nearly impossible for new entrants to catch up.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWe Learn to Use AI by Watching Others, and That Is Why Adoption Is UnevenSocial cognitive theory predicts that AI adoption clusters not by access but by observation: people adopt when they see peers succeed with AI, and the gap between teams with visible champions and those without will persist.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Output Is a Boundary Object. That Is Why It Is So Hard to Govern.Star and Griesemer defined boundary objects in 1989. AI output fits the definition perfectly. And that is why every governance policy that treats it as a single type of thing fails.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI as a Participant in the Work System, Not Only a ToolAlter's work system framework already has a slot for AI. It is not the technology element. It is the participant element.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy AI Pilots Don't Become ProductsAlmost every large organization has run an AI pilot. Very few of those pilots make it to production. That gap is not a data science problem.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYour AI Policy Is Just Your Old IT Policy With AI Pasted InAlmost every AI policy is a find-and-replaced IT acceptable-use policy. DiMaggio and Powell explain why that pattern is not lazy. It is institutional isomorphism.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Regulation: Why Every Country Is Writing Different RulesThe EU has comprehensive legislation. The US has executive orders. China has sector-specific rules. The UK has no AI-specific law. Organizations operating globally must navigate all four simultaneously.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Is Forcing IS Research Methods to Evolve. Here Is What Should Change.IS research methods assume technology is stable and humans adapt. AI inverts that assumption, and our methods have not caught up.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Safety Frameworks Are PMT Without Using the NameAI safety warnings raise threat appraisal sky high. Without coping appraisal, they produce fear control, not safety.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Security Platforms Are Governance Boundary ResourcesWhen 80% of unauthorized AI use is internal policy violations, AI security platforms are governance products, not security products.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Self-Efficacy Is the New Digital DivideAccess to AI tools is not the barrier. The belief that you can use them effectively is what separates who gains and who falls behind.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Supercomputing Alone Is Not a MoatEvery major cloud vendor now sells GPU clusters. The hardware is commodity. The capability to use it is not. Here is what Carr and Barney teach us about AI moats.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Through the Lens of Task-Technology FitGoodhue and Thompson said performance follows fit, not features. AI is a family of tools, and the wrong one for the task will fail the same way every time.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Training Data Made the Knowledge-Based View VisibleThe New York Times lawsuit against OpenAI is the Knowledge-Based View of the firm becoming visible in court and in every training data licensing negotiation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Lowers the Cost of Coordination, So Why Are Organizations Still Siloed?Transaction cost economics predicts that when AI cuts coordination costs, organizations should restructure. But they are not. What gives?
- AI & Agentic SystemsAfter AI Hallucinates, How Does It Earn Trust Back?AI trust repair is not about rebuilding a relationship. It is about recalibration. The IS trust literature has been explaining this for two decades.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Vendor Concentration Creates a New Resource DependencyPfeffer and Salancik said dependence rises when resources are critical and concentrated. AI model providers are the most concentrated critical resource in IS history.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAlgorithmic Bias: When the Model Is the PolicyWhen an algorithm screens job applicants or recommends bail conditions, it is not neutral infrastructure. It is policy, running at scale, with no judgment calls.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAutonomous AI Agents: When the System Makes Decisions Without AskingAI agents that plan, act, and iterate without human input are moving into enterprise deployment. The accountability questions this raises do not have clean answers yet.
- AI & Agentic SystemsCARE Treats Privacy as a Question of DignityMost people think digital privacy is about data breaches. Leidner and Tona's CARE framework says it is really about whether your dignity can survive digitization.
- AI & Agentic SystemsChatbots in Enterprise: When They Help and When They Don'tRule-based bots were honest about what they couldn't do. LLM-based bots can sound confident while being wrong. That's a more dangerous failure mode.
- AI & Agentic SystemsClinical Decision Support: When the Algorithm Disagrees With the DoctorCDSS tools fire alerts, suggest diagnoses, flag drug interactions. But when the algorithm is wrong and the doctor follows it anyway, who is responsible for the outcome?
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Theory I Thought Was Pointless Until My Third ReadI rolled my eyes when a study partner said critical realism was important. Three reads later I apologized, at least internally.
- AI & Agentic SystemsI Read DiMaggio and Powell While Watching Every Company Announce an AI StrategyStudying institutional theory for comps changed how I read the news. Every AI-first press release is mimetic isomorphism. I cannot unsee it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsConfidential Computing Changes the Privacy CalculusHardware-level encryption during processing changes the risk side of the privacy calculus. IS privacy models were built for a world that no longer exists.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDigital Ethics: Beyond ComplianceCompliance asks 'are we allowed to do this?' Ethics asks 'should we do this?' In most organizations, the first question is answered and the second is never asked.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDigital Provenance Is Trust Calibration InfrastructureDigital provenance (BOMs, attestation databases, watermarking) gives users verifiable information about system origin and integrity. It is the first trust calibration mechanism that works at infrastructure level rather than requiring individual evaluation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDomain-Specific AI Needs Domain-Specific Knowledge to WorkGartner says 60 percent of enterprise GenAI models will be domain-specific by 2028. But a domain-specific model cannot compensate for an organization that lacks domain-specific prior knowledge.
- AI & Agentic SystemsEdge AI Moves Computation Into the Physical World. STS Says That Changes Everything.When AI runs on a factory sensor or hospital monitor instead of the cloud, the technical subsystem becomes physically distributed and harder to monitor. STS theory warned us seventy years ago what happens next.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe EU AI Act Is Institutional Theory Playing Out in Real TimeThe EU AI Act hits all three of Scott's institutional pillars at once. Here is why that makes it the most consequential IS policy since GDPR.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe EU AI Act and What It Means for IS PractitionersThe EU AI Act is now in force. If you build or deploy AI that touches EU users, you are in a regulated space whether or not you planned for it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy IS Research Keeps Extending TAM Instead of Replacing ItTAM was built for email and word processors. Now it explains AI agents, blockchain, and VR. The IS field knows how to replace theories, so why does it keep choosing extension instead?
- AI & Agentic SystemsYour AI Strategy Found the Problem It Wanted to SolveCohen, March and Olsen showed that in real organizations, solutions arrive before problems. The AI strategy wave is the clearest recent example.
- AI & Agentic SystemsGenerative AI in Enterprise: Four Governance Problems Treated as OneEnterprise AI governance involves at least four distinct problems. Most organizations are still treating them as one.
- AI & Agentic SystemsGPU Dependency Is Resource Dependency Theory in a $200B MarketPfeffer and Salancik predicted this. When one supplier controls access to a critical resource, power concentrates. NVIDIA at 80% GPU market share changes everything.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYou Are Not Your Job TitleMost technology resistance is not about the technology. When a tool threatens who someone believes they are, rejection is identity-consistent, not irrational.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy So Many AI Strategies Look AlikeMost organizations adopting AI are not making rational decisions. They are responding to coercive, mimetic, and normative pressure that makes copying feel like strategy.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhat You Can Actually Do with an IS Degree in 2026IS sits between technology and management, and that positioning opens more paths than most people realize, including some that didn't exist five years ago.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDeLone and McLean's IS Success Model Works for AI If You Flip Who the User IsDeLone and McLean's IS success model applies to AI systems when you expand 'user' to include both humans and the downstream systems that consume AI output.
- AI & Agentic SystemsIS Research Has an Environmental Cost Problem It Mostly IgnoresDigital infrastructure consumes significant electricity. IS researchers studying digital transformation should be asking who measures, reports, and governs the IT carbon footprint.
- AI & Agentic SystemsLarge Language Models and the Transformation of Knowledge WorkLLMs are different from earlier automation. The right question is not which jobs will disappear but which tasks inside each job will change, and what that leaves behind.
- AI & Agentic SystemsMLOps: Taking Machine Learning in Production SeriouslyMost ML models fail after deployment, not during training. MLOps is the discipline that finally takes production seriously.
- AI & Agentic SystemsModel Collapse Is Path Dependence Hitting AI Training DataThe same path dependence and absorptive capacity dynamics that explain organizational learning traps also explain why models degrade when trained on their own output.
- AI & Agentic SystemsMultiagent Systems Are Mainly a Coordination ProblemGartner says multiagent systems inquiries surged 1,445% but the real gap is not better agents. It is coordination architecture.
- AI & Agentic SystemsOpen-Weight AI Is Digital Commons Theory at Global ScaleOpen-weight AI is digital commons at global scale. The question is not open versus closed but governance design, and Ostrom's principles tell us where to start.
- AI & Agentic SystemsRLHF Is Structuration Theory: We Train AI, Then AI Trains UsRLHF mirrors Giddens' duality of structure, creating a recursive loop where human preferences shape AI outputs and reshape human preferences.
- AI & Agentic SystemsOrganizations Don't Choose Tech, They Rationalize ItWeick's sensemaking theory says people act first and make sense later, preferring plausibility over accuracy. That explains everything from the Twitter rebrand to EU AI regulation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsShadow AI Is the New Shadow ITEmployees are pasting internal documents into consumer AI tools. The risk profile is different from shadow IT, but the pattern is identical.
- AI & Agentic SystemsShadow AI Is Shadow IT All Over Again, Just FasterFollowing Ferneley and Sobreperez, three workaround types explain why employees bypass official AI tools. Shadow AI is task-technology fit failure, not compliance failure.
- AI & Agentic SystemsStop Counting Users, Start Measuring DelegationWhy 'use' is the wrong construct for agentic AI, and what delegation theory actually means for how we study human-AI interaction.
- AI & Agentic SystemsSynthetic Data: Training AI Without Real People's InformationSynthetic data offers a way to train AI on sensitive domains without exposing real people's records. The privacy tradeoff is real but often misunderstood.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Specification Error in Your Trust VariableTrust, trustworthiness, reliance, and delegation operate at different levels with different antecedents. Treating them as interchangeable is not a measurement choice, it is a theoretical mistake.
- AI & Agentic SystemsVibe Coding Is Sociotechnical Systems Theory Testing Its LimitsAI-native platforms let anyone generate code from a prompt. Trist and Bamforth showed in 1951 why optimizing only the technical subsystem creates a maintenance crisis.
- AI & Agentic SystemsExplainable AI as Sensemaking: Why Plausibility Matters Alongside AccuracyWeick said people prefer plausible stories over accurate ones. XAI built tools for accuracy. It has been solving the wrong problem since 1995.
No notes found. Try another word or topic.