Field Notes ยท Topic

Comps & Reflections

Personal reflections, comps preparation notes, PhD life, and field-level observations on the practice of IS research.

83 notes

  1. Comps & ReflectionsBought a $2M Platform, Nobody Learned a ThingOrganizations buy expensive analytics platforms and learn nothing. The theory of absorptive capacity explains why prior knowledge, not capital, determines whether new technology becomes intelligence or noise.6 min read
  2. AI & Agentic SystemsWhen the Algorithm Fails, Who Takes the Call?Agency theory explains IT outsourcing and governance through principals, agents, and monitoring. AI rewrites the problem in a way the original framework did not anticipate.6 min read
  3. AI & Agentic SystemsThe Internet of Agents Will Be Built by Platforms That Own the ProtocolThe platform that controls the agent communication protocol will control the Internet of Agents, just as Google owned search and Apple owned mobile.6 min read
  4. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Follows the S-Curve. Most Organizations Are Still in the Chasm.Rogers showed that innovation adoption follows an S-curve. Enterprise AI is not stalling. It is exactly where diffusion theory predicts.6 min read
  5. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Spreads Through Social Networks as Much as Tech BudgetsRogers, Granovetter, and Burt explain why the department with the AI champion adopts faster while the department across the building with the same budget does not.7 min read
  6. AI & Agentic SystemsWhy AI Adoption Produces ROI for Some and a Headache for OthersTOE from Tornatzky and Fleischer explains why most AI investments fail while a few transform organizations: the three contexts must align.6 min read
  7. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Creates an Ambidexterity Challenge Every Organization Is FailingOrganizations use AI to optimize existing processes while calling it transformation. March (1991) would call this pure exploitation, and the exploration gap is getting dangerous.6 min read
  8. AI & Agentic SystemsCopilot Generated More Code and More BugsThirty percent acceptance is adoption, not effective use. Burton-Jones and Grange defined effective use as faithful domain representation, not output.6 min read
  9. AI & Agentic SystemsWhy Doctors Resist Better AI: Identity Matters as Much as AccuracyAI outperforms radiologists at detection but hospitals do not adopt it. Identity theory explains why. The tools that succeed will verify professional identity, not threaten it.6 min read
  10. AI & Agentic SystemsCritical Realism Explains Why AI Models Are Not the Mechanisms They SimulateAI models predict patterns in observed data but never access the generative mechanisms that produce them. Critical realism tells us why that ceiling is not a technical problem.6 min read
  11. AI & Agentic SystemsTiny Teams, Big Questions: What Happens When AI Writes the CodeGartner says two-person AI-augmented teams will deliver what twenty-person teams do today. Baird and Maruping predicted this years ago. The real question is not team size but delegation governance.6 min read
  12. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Has The Strongest Network Effects Ever, And That Is a ProblemNetwork effects theory explains why AI markets concentrate around a few providers and why the data flywheel makes it nearly impossible for new entrants to catch up.5 min read
  13. AI & Agentic SystemsWe Learn to Use AI by Watching Others, and That Is Why Adoption Is UnevenSocial cognitive theory predicts that AI adoption clusters not by access but by observation: people adopt when they see peers succeed with AI, and the gap between teams with visible champions and those without will persist.6 min read
  14. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Output Is a Boundary Object. That Is Why It Is So Hard to Govern.Star and Griesemer defined boundary objects in 1989. AI output fits the definition perfectly. And that is why every governance policy that treats it as a single type of thing fails.5 min read
  15. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Regulation: Why Every Country Is Writing Different RulesThe EU has comprehensive legislation. The US has executive orders. China has sector-specific rules. The UK has no AI-specific law. Organizations operating globally must navigate all four simultaneously.6 min read
  16. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Security Platforms Are Governance Boundary ResourcesWhen 80% of unauthorized AI use is internal policy violations, AI security platforms are governance products, not security products.6 min read
  17. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Self-Efficacy Is the New Digital DivideAccess to AI tools is not the barrier. The belief that you can use them effectively is what separates who gains and who falls behind.6 min read
  18. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Through the Lens of Task-Technology FitGoodhue and Thompson said performance follows fit, not features. AI is a family of tools, and the wrong one for the task will fail the same way every time.5 min read
  19. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Training Data Made the Knowledge-Based View VisibleThe New York Times lawsuit against OpenAI is the Knowledge-Based View of the firm becoming visible in court and in every training data licensing negotiation.6 min read
  20. AI & Agentic SystemsAI Lowers the Cost of Coordination, So Why Are Organizations Still Siloed?Transaction cost economics predicts that when AI cuts coordination costs, organizations should restructure. But they are not. What gives?6 min read
  21. AI & Agentic SystemsAfter AI Hallucinates, How Does It Earn Trust Back?AI trust repair is not about rebuilding a relationship. It is about recalibration. The IS trust literature has been explaining this for two decades.6 min read
  22. AI & Agentic SystemsAlgorithmic Bias: When the Model Is the PolicyWhen an algorithm screens job applicants or recommends bail conditions, it is not neutral infrastructure. It is policy, running at scale, with no judgment calls.6 min read
  23. Comps & ReflectionsStrategy Is What Your Organization Actually Pays Attention ToOcasio's attention-based view says firm behavior follows what executives notice, not what they intend. Attention is the scarcest organizational resource.6 min read
  24. Comps & ReflectionsWhy the Spreadsheet Everyone Complains About SurvivesStar and Griesemer's boundary objects are plastic enough to serve local needs but robust enough to hold shared identity. That is why the spreadsheet survives.6 min read
  25. Comps & ReflectionsBI Tools and Analytics Culture Are Not the Same ThingMost organizations have dashboards showing last month's numbers and call it data-driven. That is BI. An analytics culture is something different, and harder.5 min read
  26. AI & Agentic SystemsClinical Decision Support: When the Algorithm Disagrees With the DoctorCDSS tools fire alerts, suggest diagnoses, flag drug interactions. But when the algorithm is wrong and the doctor follows it anyway, who is responsible for the outcome?6 min read
  27. Comps & ReflectionsThree Hours on One Page of Orlikowski and Iacono (2001)I had read Orlikowski and Iacono before. Three hours on one page taught me what I had missed about the five views of the IT artifact.6 min read
  28. Comps & ReflectionsWhy I Keep Rereading the Same 20 PapersEach reread of the same foundational IS papers reveals something new: the claim, then the evidence, then the limits, then the connections across decades.6 min read
  29. AI & Agentic SystemsI Read DiMaggio and Powell While Watching Every Company Announce an AI StrategyStudying institutional theory for comps changed how I read the news. Every AI-first press release is mimetic isomorphism. I cannot unsee it.6 min read
  30. Comps & ReflectionsMarkus and Robey 1988 Keep Showing UpThe further I get into comps, the more I see Markus and Robey's three causal stances in every paper. It is not just one paper anymore. It is the lens.6 min read