Field Notes ยท Topic
Comps & Reflections
Personal reflections, comps preparation notes, PhD life, and field-level observations on the practice of IS research.
- Comps & ReflectionsBought a $2M Platform, Nobody Learned a ThingOrganizations buy expensive analytics platforms and learn nothing. The theory of absorptive capacity explains why prior knowledge, not capital, determines whether new technology becomes intelligence or noise.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhen the Algorithm Fails, Who Takes the Call?Agency theory explains IT outsourcing and governance through principals, agents, and monitoring. AI rewrites the problem in a way the original framework did not anticipate.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe Internet of Agents Will Be Built by Platforms That Own the ProtocolThe platform that controls the agent communication protocol will control the Internet of Agents, just as Google owned search and Apple owned mobile.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Follows the S-Curve. Most Organizations Are Still in the Chasm.Rogers showed that innovation adoption follows an S-curve. Enterprise AI is not stalling. It is exactly where diffusion theory predicts.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Adoption Spreads Through Social Networks as Much as Tech BudgetsRogers, Granovetter, and Burt explain why the department with the AI champion adopts faster while the department across the building with the same budget does not.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy AI Adoption Produces ROI for Some and a Headache for OthersTOE from Tornatzky and Fleischer explains why most AI investments fail while a few transform organizations: the three contexts must align.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Creates an Ambidexterity Challenge Every Organization Is FailingOrganizations use AI to optimize existing processes while calling it transformation. March (1991) would call this pure exploitation, and the exploration gap is getting dangerous.
- AI & Agentic SystemsCopilot Generated More Code and More BugsThirty percent acceptance is adoption, not effective use. Burton-Jones and Grange defined effective use as faithful domain representation, not output.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhy Doctors Resist Better AI: Identity Matters as Much as AccuracyAI outperforms radiologists at detection but hospitals do not adopt it. Identity theory explains why. The tools that succeed will verify professional identity, not threaten it.
- AI & Agentic SystemsCritical Realism Explains Why AI Models Are Not the Mechanisms They SimulateAI models predict patterns in observed data but never access the generative mechanisms that produce them. Critical realism tells us why that ceiling is not a technical problem.
- AI & Agentic SystemsTiny Teams, Big Questions: What Happens When AI Writes the CodeGartner says two-person AI-augmented teams will deliver what twenty-person teams do today. Baird and Maruping predicted this years ago. The real question is not team size but delegation governance.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Has The Strongest Network Effects Ever, And That Is a ProblemNetwork effects theory explains why AI markets concentrate around a few providers and why the data flywheel makes it nearly impossible for new entrants to catch up.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWe Learn to Use AI by Watching Others, and That Is Why Adoption Is UnevenSocial cognitive theory predicts that AI adoption clusters not by access but by observation: people adopt when they see peers succeed with AI, and the gap between teams with visible champions and those without will persist.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Output Is a Boundary Object. That Is Why It Is So Hard to Govern.Star and Griesemer defined boundary objects in 1989. AI output fits the definition perfectly. And that is why every governance policy that treats it as a single type of thing fails.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Regulation: Why Every Country Is Writing Different RulesThe EU has comprehensive legislation. The US has executive orders. China has sector-specific rules. The UK has no AI-specific law. Organizations operating globally must navigate all four simultaneously.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Security Platforms Are Governance Boundary ResourcesWhen 80% of unauthorized AI use is internal policy violations, AI security platforms are governance products, not security products.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Self-Efficacy Is the New Digital DivideAccess to AI tools is not the barrier. The belief that you can use them effectively is what separates who gains and who falls behind.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Through the Lens of Task-Technology FitGoodhue and Thompson said performance follows fit, not features. AI is a family of tools, and the wrong one for the task will fail the same way every time.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Training Data Made the Knowledge-Based View VisibleThe New York Times lawsuit against OpenAI is the Knowledge-Based View of the firm becoming visible in court and in every training data licensing negotiation.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAI Lowers the Cost of Coordination, So Why Are Organizations Still Siloed?Transaction cost economics predicts that when AI cuts coordination costs, organizations should restructure. But they are not. What gives?
- AI & Agentic SystemsAfter AI Hallucinates, How Does It Earn Trust Back?AI trust repair is not about rebuilding a relationship. It is about recalibration. The IS trust literature has been explaining this for two decades.
- AI & Agentic SystemsAlgorithmic Bias: When the Model Is the PolicyWhen an algorithm screens job applicants or recommends bail conditions, it is not neutral infrastructure. It is policy, running at scale, with no judgment calls.
- Comps & ReflectionsStrategy Is What Your Organization Actually Pays Attention ToOcasio's attention-based view says firm behavior follows what executives notice, not what they intend. Attention is the scarcest organizational resource.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy the Spreadsheet Everyone Complains About SurvivesStar and Griesemer's boundary objects are plastic enough to serve local needs but robust enough to hold shared identity. That is why the spreadsheet survives.
- Comps & ReflectionsBI Tools and Analytics Culture Are Not the Same ThingMost organizations have dashboards showing last month's numbers and call it data-driven. That is BI. An analytics culture is something different, and harder.
- AI & Agentic SystemsClinical Decision Support: When the Algorithm Disagrees With the DoctorCDSS tools fire alerts, suggest diagnoses, flag drug interactions. But when the algorithm is wrong and the doctor follows it anyway, who is responsible for the outcome?
- Comps & ReflectionsThree Hours on One Page of Orlikowski and Iacono (2001)I had read Orlikowski and Iacono before. Three hours on one page taught me what I had missed about the five views of the IT artifact.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy I Keep Rereading the Same 20 PapersEach reread of the same foundational IS papers reveals something new: the claim, then the evidence, then the limits, then the connections across decades.
- AI & Agentic SystemsI Read DiMaggio and Powell While Watching Every Company Announce an AI StrategyStudying institutional theory for comps changed how I read the news. Every AI-first press release is mimetic isomorphism. I cannot unsee it.
- Comps & ReflectionsMarkus and Robey 1988 Keep Showing UpThe further I get into comps, the more I see Markus and Robey's three causal stances in every paper. It is not just one paper anymore. It is the lens.
- Comps & ReflectionsMy Comps Study Notes Are a DisasterMy comps notes are a wreck of sticky notes, marginalia, and inconsistent filenames. The mess is not a sign of failure. It is how real understanding happens.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Practice Exam Question I Got Wrong That Changed EverythingI answered a practice comps question about coercive isomorphism completely wrong. That mistake reshaped how I study for exams.
- Comps & ReflectionsMy Study Partner Said I Was Wrong About Structuration TheoryI confused structuration theory's three modalities with institutional theory's three pillars for months. A study partner caught it, and getting corrected was the best thing that happened to my comps prep.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Theory Map That Keeps GrowingOne page of sticky notes became a wall of connected IS theories. RBV, dynamic capabilities, structuration, affordances, institutional theory: the connections between them matter as much as the theories themselves.
- Comps & Reflections56% of IS Papers Do Not Theorize TechnologyReading Sarker et al. (2019) for the third time during comps prep, the 56% stat finally hit me: more than half of IS papers do not theorize technology at all.
- AI & Agentic SystemsConfidential Computing Changes the Privacy CalculusHardware-level encryption during processing changes the risk side of the privacy calculus. IS privacy models were built for a world that no longer exists.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe CrowdStrike Outage and Why Every 'Minor Update' Is a Structural RiskA routine config update grounded airlines and froze hospitals. The risk was not the update but the architecture that pushed it everywhere at once.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy No One Reads Your DashboardDashboards fail when they are built for reporting instead of decision-making. DeLone and McLean show why, and Torres and Sidorova show what to do about it.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Digital Divide Is Not Just About AccessSubsidized broadband matters. But the gap between having internet and using it to improve your life is wider than the access frame admits.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDigital Ethics: Beyond ComplianceCompliance asks 'are we allowed to do this?' Ethics asks 'should we do this?' In most organizations, the first question is answered and the second is never asked.
- Comps & ReflectionsDigital Identity: Who Are You, Online?Most people have dozens of digital identities that don't talk to each other. The vision of user-controlled identity has been under development for years and remains largely unrealized.
- Comps & ReflectionsWho Designed That Default? You Did.Every default in a digital system is a design choice with behavioral consequences. IS designers are choice architects whether they admit it or not.
- AI & Agentic SystemsDigital Provenance Is Trust Calibration InfrastructureDigital provenance (BOMs, attestation databases, watermarking) gives users verifiable information about system origin and integrity. It is the first trust calibration mechanism that works at infrastructure level rather than requiring individual evaluation.
- Comps & ReflectionsDigital Sovereignty and the Politics of Where Your Data LivesWhere data is stored and processed has become a geopolitical question, not just a technical one. GDPR, Schrems II, and chip export controls explain why.
- Comps & ReflectionsLogging In Is Not UsingNinety percent login rates tell you almost nothing about whether a system is doing its job. Burton-Jones and Grange showed why measuring adoption instead of effective use is the wrong question.
- AI & Agentic SystemsThe EU AI Act and What It Means for IS PractitionersThe EU AI Act is now in force. If you build or deploy AI that touches EU users, you are in a regulated space whether or not you planned for it.
- Comps & ReflectionsFinTech and the Bank That Still Runs on COBOLStripe and Chime built modern financial infrastructure from scratch while banks ran on mainframes from the 1970s. The gap is real, but the narrative oversimplifies.
- AI & Agentic SystemsYour AI Strategy Found the Problem It Wanted to SolveCohen, March and Olsen showed that in real organizations, solutions arrive before problems. The AI strategy wave is the clearest recent example.
- Comps & ReflectionsGeopatriation Is Institutional Logics Colliding with Cloud StrategyGeopatriation is not a cloud architecture decision. It is an institutional choice about which logic dominates.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Gig Economy Is a Platform Governance ProblemUber sets the prices, assigns the work, and deactivates accounts. Calling that 'independent contracting' is a governance choice, not a neutral fact.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Great Resignation and What It Revealed About IT TalentThe Great Resignation hit the IS workforce hard. Organizations discovered how much institutional knowledge had been quietly sitting in people who had just left.
- Comps & ReflectionsHealth IT Interoperability: Why Your Doctor Still Sends FaxesThe US has spent billions on EHRs since 2009. Patient records still don't move between systems. Fax machines still work. Here's why.
- Comps & ReflectionsInstitutional Entrepreneurship: Who Gets to Change the Rules?Institutional theory explains why organizations conform. Institutional entrepreneurship explains who breaks that conformity and rewrites the rules everyone else must follow.
- AI & Agentic SystemsWhat You Can Actually Do with an IS Degree in 2026IS sits between technology and management, and that positioning opens more paths than most people realize, including some that didn't exist five years ago.
- Comps & ReflectionsIS Consulting vs. IS Academia: An Honest ComparisonBoth paths study organizations and technology. The differences in how they do it, and what you give up, are rarely described honestly.
- Comps & ReflectionsIS in Developing Countries: The Assumptions That Don't TravelMost IS theory was built in high-income countries with reliable infrastructure. When you apply those assumptions in LMICs, many of them fall apart immediately.
- Comps & ReflectionsIS Journals and How the Publishing Game Actually WorksAcademic publishing in IS is slow, opaque, and high-stakes. Understanding the game is as important as doing good research.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhat IS PhD Programs Teach and What They Don'tGoing through an IS PhD program has been genuinely valuable. It has also revealed some consistent gaps between what the curriculum covers and what doing IS research actually requires.
- Comps & ReflectionsIT Outsourcing: Why We Keep Doing the Same ThingOrganizations outsource IT, run into problems, bring it back in-house, then outsource again. The cycle is predictable. The reasons it repeats are not mysterious.
- Comps & ReflectionsIT Project Portfolio Management: Why You Have Too Many ProjectsMost organizations have more IT projects in flight than they can deliver. Portfolio management theory says say no. Organizational politics make saying no nearly impossible.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy Knowledge Management Systems Usually FailNonaka's SECI model explains why most knowledge management systems only solve half the problem, and the easy half at that.
- AI & Agentic SystemsLarge Language Models and the Transformation of Knowledge WorkLLMs are different from earlier automation. The right question is not which jobs will disappear but which tasks inside each job will change, and what that leaves behind.
- Comps & ReflectionsMental Health Apps: Good Intentions, Mixed EvidenceHundreds of millions of people have downloaded mental health apps. The clinical evidence is mixed, the privacy practices are questionable, and the regulation barely touches it.
- Comps & ReflectionsMisinformation and What Platform Design Choices Actually DoPlatform ranking algorithms are not neutral pipes. When they optimize for engagement, outrage and false information spread faster. That is a design outcome, not a side effect.
- AI & Agentic SystemsOpen-Weight AI Is Digital Commons Theory at Global ScaleOpen-weight AI is digital commons at global scale. The question is not open versus closed but governance design, and Ostrom's principles tell us where to start.
- Comps & ReflectionsPreemptive Cybersecurity Needs Protection Motivation Theory to WorkPredicting attacks is useless if nobody acts on the warning. PMT explains why organizations stall on preemptive security.
- Comps & ReflectionsRemote Work and IS: What Actually ChangedCOVID-19 forced the largest unplanned IS deployment in history. What it revealed about organizations was not what most people expected.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhen a New Label on an Old Idea Falls Short of a ContributionMost IS papers are improvements dressed as inventions. Sun et al. say you need novelty, rigor, and relevance, not two out of three.
- AI & Agentic SystemsShadow AI Is Shadow IT All Over Again, Just FasterFollowing Ferneley and Sobreperez, three workaround types explain why employees bypass official AI tools. Shadow AI is task-technology fit failure, not compliance failure.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Network You Have Is Part of the SystemSocial capital theory says the network around a system determines whether the system works. IS treats this network as a constant. It is not.
- Comps & ReflectionsSupply Chain Digitization: What COVID-19 RevealedCOVID-19 didn't break supply chains. It revealed how much fragility had been building for decades. The digital response is real, but the problems aren't primarily technological.
- Comps & ReflectionsSurveillance Capitalism and What Your Data Is Actually ForZuboff's argument is not just that companies collect too much data. It is that behavioral data has become raw material for a specific economic logic aimed at predicting and modifying what you do next.
- AI & Agentic SystemsSynthetic Data: Training AI Without Real People's InformationSynthetic data offers a way to train AI on sensitive domains without exposing real people's records. The privacy tradeoff is real but often misunderstood.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe Tool Is Not Broken. It's Just Wrong for Your Job.Goodhue and Thompson showed that performance depends on fit between task and technology, not on whether the tool is good in the abstract.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe System That Teaches NothingEnterprise knowledge systems capture what can be written down and miss everything else. Argyris, Nonaka, and Cohen tell us why.
- Comps & ReflectionsTelehealth After COVID: What Stuck and What Didn'tCOVID forced telehealth adoption overnight. The waivers, the reimbursement, the video calls. Now the question is which parts of that experiment actually held.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe IT Artifact Is Not Optional56% of IS papers study the social side without theorizing technology at all. The field's identity crisis is not rhetorical. The numbers show it is real.
- Comps & ReflectionsThe S-Curve Does Not Care About Your Launch DateRogers showed that the S-curve is a social process with five failure points built in. Most product teams read it as a timeline and miss the diagnostic entirely.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy the Same CRM Thrives in One City and Dies in AnotherThe TOE framework explains why identical technology adoption fails in one organization and succeeds in another: context is not background, it is the whole story.
- Comps & ReflectionsOne Million Vulnerabilities and Counting: Why Patching Alone Cannot ScaleGartner projects one million vulnerabilities annually by 2030. Patching cannot scale. The only move is to reconfigure how the firm approaches software risk.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhat Makes a Good IS Paper?Technically correct IS papers fail all the time. The difference between a paper that passes review and one that advances the field is harder to name than it sounds.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhy IT Projects Keep Running Late and Over BudgetThe Standish Group has tracked IT project outcomes for decades. The numbers have barely moved. This is a structural problem, not a competence problem.
- Comps & ReflectionsWhen Employees Break the System, That's a Requirements DocumentFerneley and Sobreperez argued workarounds are not user failure but evidence of system-task misfit. The workaround is the real requirements document.
No notes found. Try another word or topic.